Effectiveness of Alternative Treatments for Depression
Which alternative treatments work for depression? A succinct summary of the scientific evidence.
Most people with depression try to manage the illness themselves. Some of these self-management approaches have undergone some reasonable scientific testing and can therefore be tried, especially when the depression is not severe or life-threatening.
-
Some common strategies like drinking more alcohol or smoking cannabis are clearly unhelpful.
-
Other people try alternative therapies or adjusting their life-cycle. Some activities like increased physical activity or attention to sleep patterns are clearly beneficial.
-
Herbal remedies for depression and other alternative health practices may be either helpful or harmful.
-
Some of these approaches have undergone some reasonable scientific testing and can therefore be tried, especially when the depression is not severe or life-threatening. Treatments in the 'poor evidence' box below need more studies to see whether they are helpful or not.
TABLE 1. EVIDENCE-BASE OF DIFFERENT ALTERNATIVE TREATMENTS FOR DEPRESSION
Good Evidence | Some Evidence | Poor Evidence |
- St John's Wort - Physical exercise - Self-help books involving cognitive behavior therapy - Light therapy (for winter depression) | - Acupuncture - Light therapy (for non-seasonal depression) - Massage therapy - Negative air ionisation (for winter depression) - Relaxation therapy - SAMe (S-Adenosylmethionine)* - Folate - Yoga breathing exercises | - Ginseng - Lemon balm - Painkillers - Vervain# - Colour therapy - Prayer - Chocolate |
*SAMe is an amino acid that occurs naturally in cells. # Vervain is a traditional herbal remedy for depression consisting of the aerial parts of a flowering plant.
Source: Jorm AF, Christensen H, Griffiths KM, Rodgers B. Effectiveness of complementary and self-help treatments for depression. MJA 2002; 176 Suppl
May 20: p. S84-96.
next: Full Description of all Alternative Treatments for Depression
APA Reference
Staff, H.
(2008, October 24). Effectiveness of Alternative Treatments for Depression, HealthyPlace. Retrieved
on 2024, December 8 from https://www.healthyplace.com/alternative-mental-health/depression-alternative/effectiveness-of-alternative-treatments-for-depression